This is an original way of voting.
Anyways, those are my votes:

0-3 Illusion City - World Golf
2-1 Zanac Ex - Skooter
0-3 Super Pierrot - Boulderdash
2-1 Alpha Blaster - Return of Yelda
0-3 Dawn Patrol - Magical Kid Wiz
2-1 Star Soldier - Treppy
0-3 Alpha Roid - Hype
3-0 Maze Runner (Disk Station 27) - Musical Memory
0-3 Psycho World - The Castle
2-1 Rune Worth - Hardboiled
3-0 Girly Block - Zoom 909
1-2 Vaxol - Retaliator
1-2 Topple Zip - Eric & The Floaters
2-1 Testament - Woody Poco
3-0 Twin Bee - Greatest Driver 2D Special
3-0 La Abadia del Crimen - Guardic
0-3 Fireball - Abu Simbel Profanation
2-1 Sa-Zi-Ri - Super Runner
3-0 Choplifter - Crossblaim
1-2 SD Gundam - Xyzolog
2-1 Vamper (Phantomas 2) - Mr. Ghost
2-1 Army Moves 2 - BMX Simulator
1-2 Rambo - Frantic
2-1 Breaker Breaker - Sokoban
2-1 Hyper Somen - Demand
1-2 Rotors - Radx-8
0-3 IRI Gas Episode IV - Daiva
2-1 Ryukyu - Push 'em
0-3 Footballer of the Year - Football Manager
0-3 Greatest Driver - Inspector Z
0-3 Feedback - Starship Rendezvous
2-1 Magical Tree - Family Billiards
1-2 Zoo - Fairyland Story
1-2 Rock 'n Bolt - Breaker
2-1 Herzog - Kyokugen
3-0 Pinball (T&E Soft) - F-Nano2
2-1 Higemaru - Konami Billiards
2-1 Mister Ghost - Grog's Revenge
0-3 Red Zone - TNT
0-3 Finders Keepers - Temptations
0-3 Pleasure Hearts - Konami's Ping Pong
2-1 Ark-a-Noah - Super Ninja 2
2-1 Step-up - Druid
3-0Payload - Bosconian
2-1 Super Cooks - Sorcery
2-1 Traffic - Roller Ball
1-2 Star Quake - Elite
1-2 Firehawk (Thexder 2) - Sex Bomb Bunny
2-1 Green Beret - Don't cock it up
3-0 Quinpl - Moskow 2024
3-0 Strategic Mars - Core Dump (unreleased)
0-3 Zorax - 1942 (MSX2)
3-0 Undeadline - Ankanbe Dragon
0-3 Princess Maker - Wizard's Lair
2-1 Mirror Maze (Peach Up) - Cannon Ball
1-2 Seed of Dragon - Troxx

Ok! Here we go !!

(2-1)Illusion City - World Golf
(3-0)Zanac Ex - Skooter
(1-2)Super Pierrot - Boulderdash
(3-0)Alpha Blaster - Return of Yelda
(1-2)Dawn Patrol - Magical Kid Wiz
(0-3)Star Soldier - Treppy
(0-3)Alpha Roid - Hype
(3-0)Maze Runner (Disk Station 27) - Musical Memory
(2-1)Psycho World - The Castle
(2-1)Rune Worth - Hardboiled
(3-0)Girly Block - Zoom 909
(3-0)Vaxol - Retaliator
(1-2)Topple Zip - Eric & The Floaters
(2-1)Testament - Woody Poco
(1-2)Twin Bee - Greatest Driver 2D Special
(3-0)La Abadia del Crimen - Guardic
(0-3)Fireball - Abu Simbel Profanation
(1-2)Sa-Zi-Ri - Super Runner
(1-2)Choplifter - Crossblaim
(2-1)SD Gundam - Xyzolog
(1-2)Vamper (Phantomas 2) - Mr. Ghost
(3-0)Army Moves 2 - BMX Simulator
(2-1)Rambo - Frantic
(3-0)Breaker Breaker - Sokoban
(0-3)Hyper Somen - Demand
(1-2)Rotors - Radx-8
(3-0)IRI Gas Episode IV - Daiva
(2-1)Ryukyu - Push 'em
(2-1)Footballer of the Year - Football Manager
(1-2)Greatest Driver - Inspector Z
(2-1)Feedback - Starship Rendezvous
(1-2)Magical Tree - Family Billiards
(0-3)Zoo - Fairyland Story
(2-1)Rock 'n Bolt - Breaker
(0-3)Herzog - Kyokugen
(1-2)Pinball (T&E Soft) - F-Nano2
(1-2)Higemaru - Konami Billiards
(3-0)Mister Ghost - Grog's Revenge
(1-2)Red Zone - TNT
(0-3)Finders Keepers - Temptations
(1-2)Pleasure Hearts - Konami's Ping Pong
(3-0)Ark-a-Noah - Super Ninja 2
(1-2)Step-up - Druid
(1-2)Payload - Bosconian
(1-2)Super Cooks - Sorcery
(0-3)Traffic - Roller Ball
(1-2)Star Quake - Elite
(1-2)Firehawk (Thexder 2) - Sex Bomb Bunny
(0-3)Green Beret - Don't cock it up
(1-2)Quinpl - Moskow 2024
(2-1)Strategic Mars - Core Dump (unreleased)
(1-2)Zorax - 1942 (MSX2)
(3-0)Undeadline - Ankanbe Dragon
(3-0)Princess Maker - Wizard's Lair
(2-1)Mirror Maze (Peach Up) - Cannon Ball
(2-1)Seed of Dragon - Troxx

Well,here are mine! greetx !

KNM

2-1 Illusion City - World Golf
2-1 Zanac Ex - Skooter
0-3 Super Pierrot - Boulderdash
1-2 Alpha Blaster - Return of Yelda
1-2 Dawn Patrol - Magical Kid Wiz
2-1 Star Soldier - Treppy
0-3 Alpha Roid - Hype
3-0 Maze Runner (Disk Station 27) - Musical Memory
3-0 Psycho World - The Castle
3-0 Rune Worth - Hardboiled
3-0 Girly Block - Zoom 909
1-2 Vaxol - Retaliator
2-1 Topple Zip - Eric & The Floaters
3-0 Testament - Woody Poco
0-3 Twin Bee - Greatest Driver 2D Special
0-3 La Abadia del Crimen - Guardic
2-1 Fireball - Abu Simbel Profanation
3-0 Sa-Zi-Ri - Super Runner
3-0 Choplifter - Crossblaim
0-3 SD Gundam - Xyzolog
0-3 Vamper (Phantomas 2) - Mr. Ghost
0-3 Army Moves 2 - BMX Simulator
2-1 Rambo - Frantic
1-2 Breaker Breaker - Sokoban
2-1 Hyper Somen - Demand
1-2 Rotors - Radx-8
1-2 IRI Gas Episode IV - Daiva
1-2 Ryukyu - Push 'em
1-2 Footballer of the Year - Football Manager
3-0 Greatest Driver - Inspector Z
2-1 Feedback - Starship Rendezvous
2-1 Magical Tree - Family Billiards
2-1 Zoo - Fairyland Story
1-2 Rock 'n Bolt - Breaker
3-0 Herzog - Kyokugen
2-1 Pinball (T&E Soft) - F-Nano2
3-0 Higemaru - Konami Billiards
0-3 Mister Ghost - Grog's Revenge
0-3 Red Zone - TNT
3-0 Finders Keepers - Temptations
1-2 Pleasure Hearts - Konami's Ping Pong
1-2 Ark-a-Noah - Super Ninja 2
1-2 Step-up - Druid
2-1 Payload - Bosconian
0-3 Super Cooks - Sorcery
0-3 Traffic - Roller Ball
2-1 Star Quake - Elite
3-0 Firehawk (Thexder 2) - Sex Bomb Bunny
3-0 Green Beret - Don't cock it up
3-0 Quinpl - Moskow 2024
3-0 Strategic Mars - Core Dump (unreleased)
0-3 Zorax - 1942 (MSX2)
1-2 Undeadline - Ankanbe Dragon
1-2 Princess Maker - Wizard's Lair
2-1 Mirror Maze (Peach Up) - Cannon Ball
3-0 Seed of Dragon - Troxx

3-0 Illusion City - World Golf
3-0 Zanac Ex - Skooter
1-2 Super Pierrot - Boulderdash
2-1 Alpha Blaster - Return of Yelda
2-1 Dawn Patrol - Magical Kid Wiz
2-1 Star Soldier - Treppy
2-1 Alpha Roid - Hype
2-1 Maze Runner (Disk Station 27) - Musical Memory
2-1 Psycho World - The Castle
2-1 Rune Worth - Hardboiled
3-0 Girly Block - Zoom 909
1-2 Vaxol - Retaliator
1-2 Topple Zip - Eric & The Floaters
3-0 Testament - Woody Poco
1-2 Twin Bee - Greatest Driver 2D Special
1-2 La Abadia del Crimen - Guardic
2-1 Fireball - Abu Simbel Profanation
2-1 Sa-Zi-Ri - Super Runner
1-2 Choplifter - Crossblaim
2-1 SD Gundam - Xyzolog
2-1 Vamper (Phantomas 2) - Mr. Ghost
2-1 Army Moves 2 - BMX Simulator
2-1 Rambo - Frantic
2-1 Breaker Breaker - Sokoban
2-1 Hyper Somen - Demand
1-2 Rotors - Radx-8
2-1 IRI Gas Episode IV - Daiva
2-1 Ryukyu - Push 'em
2-1 Footballer of the Year - Football Manager
3-0 Greatest Driver - Inspector Z
1-2 Feedback - Starship Rendezvous
0-3 Magical Tree - Family Billiards
3-0 Zoo - Fairyland Story
0-3 Rock 'n Bolt - Breaker
3-0 Herzog - Kyokugen
1-2 Pinball (T&E Soft) - F-Nano2
2-1 Higemaru - Konami Billiards
2-1 Mister Ghost - Grog's Revenge
1-2 Red Zone - TNT
2-1 Finders Keepers - Temptations
1-2 Pleasure Hearts - Konami's Ping Pong
2-1 Ark-a-Noah - Super Ninja 2
1-2 Step-up - Druid
2-1 Payload - Bosconian
2-1 Super Cooks - Sorcery
2-1 Traffic - Roller Ball
0-3 Star Quake - Elite
3-0 Firehawk (Thexder 2) - Sex Bomb Bunny
2-1 Green Beret - Don't cock it up
2-1 Quinpl - Moskow 2024
2-1 Strategic Mars - Core Dump (unreleased)
1-2 Zorax - 1942 (MSX2)
2-1 Undeadline - Ankanbe Dragon
3-0 Princess Maker - Wizard's Lair
1-2 Mirror Maze (Peach Up) - Cannon Ball
3-0 Seed of Dragon - Troxx

Damn, all those guys voting for Rollerball, while it's not underrated at all! Traffic rules!
(mfeingol put it very clearly, I think... see above)

To do honest voting: first try to get to know all the games, otherwise you can't judge if they're underrated or not...

Quote:

Damn, all those guys voting for Rollerball, while it's not underrated at all!

I think the whole concept of 'underrated' has been lost to some voters and nominators. ^^;

I thought it was 'underrated after the earlier megapolls'

I think it's time to define this entire poll.

3-0 Illusion City - World Golf
2-1 Zanac Ex - Skooter
0-3 Super Pierrot - Boulderdash
2-1 Alpha Blaster - Return of Yelda
0-3 Dawn Patrol - Magical Kid Wiz
3-0 Star Soldier - Treppy
0-3 Alpha Roid - Hype
2-1 Maze Runner (Disk Station 27) - Musical Memory
2-1 Psycho World - The Castle
3-0 Rune Worth - Hardboiled
3-0 Girly Block - Zoom 909
3-0 Vaxol - Retaliator
0-3 Topple Zip - Eric & The Floaters
1-2 Testament - Woody Poco
3-0 Twin Bee - Greatest Driver 2D Special
0-3 La Abadia del Crimen - Guardic
3-0 Fireball - Abu Simbel Profanation
0-3 Sa-Zi-Ri - Super Runner
2-1 Choplifter - Crossblaim
1-2 SD Gundam - Xyzolog
0-3 Vamper (Phantomas 2) - Mr. Ghost
3-0 Army Moves 2 - BMX Simulator
2-1 Rambo - Frantic
2-1 Breaker Breaker - Sokoban
2-1 Hyper Somen - Demand
0-3 Rotors - Radx-8
2-1 IRI Gas Episode IV - Daiva
3-0 Ryukyu - Push 'em
1-2 Footballer of the Year - Football Manager
2-1 Greatest Driver - Inspector Z
3-0 Feedback - Starship Rendezvous
1-2 Magical Tree - Family Billiards
3-0 Zoo - Fairyland Story
0-3 Rock 'n Bolt - Breaker
2-1 Herzog - Kyokugen
2-1 Pinball (T&E Soft) - F-Nano2
3-0 Higemaru - Konami Billiards
2-1 Mister Ghost - Grog's Revenge
0-3 Red Zone - TNT
2-1 Finders Keepers - Temptations
0-3 Pleasure Hearts - Konami's Ping Pong
1-2 Ark-a-Noah - Super Ninja 2
0-3 Step-up - Druid
0-3 Payload - Bosconian
1-2 Super Cooks - Sorcery
0-3 Traffic - Roller Ball
3-0 Star Quake - Elite
3-0 Firehawk (Thexder 2) - Sex Bomb Bunny
3-0 Green Beret - Don't cock it up
3-0 Quinpl - Moskow 2024
3-0 Strategic Mars - Core Dump (unreleased)
0-3 Zorax - 1942 (MSX2)
3-0 Undeadline - Ankanbe Dragon
1-2 Princess Maker - Wizard's Lair
1-2 Mirror Maze (Peach Up) - Cannon Ball
0-3 Seed of Dragon - Troxx

Pfew, that's quite a list of games!

0-3 Illusion City - World Golf
2-1 Zanac Ex - Skooter
0-3 Super Pierrot - Boulderdash
3-0 Alpha Blaster - Return of Yelda
0-3 Dawn Patrol - Magical Kid Wiz
3-0 Star Soldier - Treppy
0-3 Alpha Roid - Hype
3-0 Maze Runner (Disk Station 27) - Musical Memory
3-0 Psycho World - The Castle
2-1 Rune Worth - Hardboiled
2-1 Girly Block - Zoom 909
2-1 Vaxol - Retaliator
1-2 Topple Zip - Eric & The Floaters
3-0 Testament - Woody Poco
3-0 Twin Bee - Greatest Driver 2D Special
0-3 La Abadia del Crimen - Guardic
2-1 Fireball - Abu Simbel Profanation
0-3 Sa-Zi-Ri - Super Runner
3-0 Choplifter - Crossblaim
0-3 SD Gundam - Xyzolog
0-3 Vamper (Phantomas 2) - Mr. Ghost
2-1 Army Moves 2 - BMX Simulator
3-0 Rambo - Frantic
3-0 Breaker Breaker - Sokoban
3-0 Hyper Somen - Demand
3-0 Rotors - Radx-8
1-2 IRI Gas Episode IV - Daiva
3-0 Ryukyu - Push 'em
2-1 Footballer of the Year - Football Manager
0-3 Greatest Driver - Inspector Z
1-2 Feedback - Starship Rendezvous
2-1 Magical Tree - Family Billiards
0-3 Zoo - Fairyland Story
2-1 Rock 'n Bolt - Breaker
3-0 Herzog - Kyokugen
3-0 Pinball (T&E Soft) - F-Nano2
1-2 Higemaru - Konami Billiards
3-0 Mister Ghost - Grog's Revenge
1-2 Red Zone - TNT
1-2 Finders Keepers - Temptations
0-3 Pleasure Hearts - Konami's Ping Pong
0-3 Ark-a-Noah - Super Ninja 2
0-3 Step-up - Druid
2-1 Payload - Bosconian
3-0 Super Cooks - Sorcery
0-3 Traffic - Roller Ball
3-0 Star Quake - Elite
3-0 Firehawk (Thexder 2) - Sex Bomb Bunny
3-0 Green Beret - Don't cock it up
3-0 Quinpl - Moskow 2024
3-0 Strategic Mars - Core Dump (unreleased)
0-3 Zorax - 1942 (MSX2)
3-0 Undeadline - Ankanbe Dragon
2-1 Princess Maker - Wizard's Lair
3-0 Mirror Maze (Peach Up) - Cannon Ball
1-2 Seed of Dragon - Troxx

I guess I missed 'Feud' in the list. I though it was mentioned in the nominees thread......

Fresh

Quote:

I think it's time to define this entire poll.

Please guys, it's `just` a mega-poll, it's not like we're working on a new constitution here. Mega-polling is fun. People can use their own interpretation of 'underrated'. If we all thought the same about everything there would not even be a reason to poll, right?

BTW Mr. Ghost == Mister Ghost indeed. Will be fixed in round 2.

When are we going to organize a 'The most X-rated game'-megapoll?

For those in need of a definition of 'underrated' :

Quote:

My understanding is that we're not voting on how good a particular game is, but on how underrated a game is. So even though I think Illusion City is probably a better game than World Golf, I think more people would be likely to rate Illusion City highly than World Golf, while WG is still a really well-done game. Therefore, WG wins. On the other hand, if a game sucks, it can't be underrated by definition. So it loses. We're trying to find the game with the greatest difference between its quality and its perception. Am I right?

Wise words of mfeingol

But, it is not up to us (MRC-admins/fellow voters) to say 'hey! that game is not underrated at all!'. That's what this poll is about!

What was it again? People can't edit their posts 30 minutes after posting or something?

-500 - 3 Illusion City - World Golf
1-2 Zanac Ex - Skooter
0-3 Super Pierrot - Boulderdash
3-0 Alpha Blaster - Return of Yelda
0-3 Dawn Patrol - Magical Kid Wiz
2-1 Star Soldier - Treppy
2-1 Alpha Roid - Hype
3-0 Maze Runner (Disk Station 27) - Musical Memory
0-3 Psycho World - The Castle (PsyWorld isn't underrated at all, everyone knows it's a great game)
3-0 Rune Worth - Hardboiled
3-0 Girly Block - Zoom 909
0-3 Vaxol - Retaliator
2-1 Topple Zip - Eric & The Floaters
3-0 Testament - Woody Poco
0-3 Twin Bee - Greatest Driver 2D Special
0-3 La Abadia del Crimen - Guardic
2-1 Fireball - Abu Simbel Profanation
0-3 Sa-Zi-Ri - Super Runner
3-0 Choplifter - Crossblaim
0-3 SD Gundam - Xyzolog
3-0 Vampire (Phantomas 2) - Mr. Ghost
3-0 Army Moves 2 - BMX Simulator
0-3 Rambo - Frantic
3-0 Breaker Breaker - Sokoban
2-1 Hyper Somen - Demand
0-3 Rotors - Radx-8
0-3 IRI Gas Episode IV - Daiva
2-1 Ryukyu - Push 'em
2-1 Footballer of the Year - Football Manager
2-1 Greatest Driver - Inspector Z
0-3 Feedback - Starship Rendezvous
0-3 Magical Tree - Family Billiards
3-0 Zoo - Fairyland Story
0-3 Rock 'n Bolt - Breaker
0-3 Herzog - Kyokugen
0-3 Pinball (T&E Soft) - F-Nano2
3-0 Higemaru - Konami Billiards
3-0 Mister Ghost - Grog's Revenge
0-3 Red Zone - TNT
3-0 Finders Keepers - Temptations
0-3 Pleasure Hearts - Konami's Ping Pong
0-3 Ark-a-Noah - Super Ninja 2
0-3 Step-up - Druid
0-3 Payload - Bosconian
3-0 Super Cooks - Sorcery
0-3 Traffic - Roller Ball
3-0 Star Quake - Elite
3-0 Firehawk (Thexder 2) - Sex Bomb Bunny
3-0 Green Beret - Don't cock it up
3-0 Quinpl - Moskow 2024
3-0 Strategic Mars - Core Dump (unreleased) (how can an unreleased game be underrated??)
0-3 Zorax - 1942 (MSX2)
0-3 Undeadline - Ankanbe Dragon (since when is Undeadline an underrated game?!)
3-0 Princess Maker - Wizard's Lair
3-0 Mirror Maze (Peach Up) - Cannon Ball
0-3 Seed of Dragon - Troxx

Some strange titles in the list, indeed. IllusionCity, Psycho World, Undeadline and CoreDump have to be eliminated a.s.a.p. since they're in no way underrated afaik.

3 - 0 Illusion City - World Golf
2 - 1 Zanac Ex - Skooter
1 - 2 Super Pierrot - Boulderdash
1 - 2 Alpha Blaster - Return of Yelda
0 - 3 Dawn Patrol - Magical Kid Wiz
3 - 0 Star Soldier - Treppy
2 - 1 Alpha Roid - Hype
2 - 1 Maze Runner (Disk Station 27) - Musical Memory
2 - 1 Psycho World - The Castle
3 - 0 Rune Worth - Hardboiled
3 - 0 Girly Block - Zoom 909
2 - 1 Vaxol - Retaliator
2 - 1 Topple Zip - Eric & The Floaters
3 - 0 Testament - Woody Poco
1 - 2 Twin Bee - Greatest Driver 2D Special
1 - 2 La Abadia del Crimen - Guardic
2 - 1 Fireball - Abu Simbel Profanation
2 - 1 Sa-Zi-Ri - Super Runner
3 - 0 Choplifter - Crossblaim
2 - 1 SD Gundam - Xyzolog
1 - 2 Vampire (Phantomas 2) - Mr. Ghost
2 - 1 Army Moves 2 - BMX Simulator
1 - 2 Rambo - Frantic
2 - 1 Breaker Breaker - Sokoban
3 - 0 Hyper Somen - Demand
2 - 1 Rotors - Radx-8
0 - 3 IRI Gas Episode IV - Daiva
2 - 1 Ryukyu - Push 'em
1 - 2 Footballer of the Year - Football Manager
1 - 2 Greatest Driver - Inspector Z
2 - 1 Feedback - Starship Rendezvous
1 - 2 Magical Tree - Family Billiards
2 - 1 Zoo - Fairyland Story
0 - 3 Rock 'n Bolt - Breaker
2 - 1 Herzog - Kyokugen
0 - 3 Pinball (T&E Soft) - F-Nano2
2 - 1 Higemaru - Konami Billiards
2 - 1 Mister Ghost - Grog's Revenge
0 - 3 Red Zone - TNT
1 - 2 Finders Keepers - Temptations
0 - 3 Pleasure Hearts - Konami's Ping Pong
1 - 2 Ark-a-Noah - Super Ninja 2
1 - 2 Step-up - Druid
3 - 0 Payload - Bosconian
2 - 1 Super Cooks - Sorcery
0 - 3 Traffic - Roller Ball
1 - 2 Star Quake - Elite
2 - 1 Firehawk (Thexder 2) - Sex Bomb Bunny
3 - 0 Green Beret - Don't cock it up
1 - 2 Quinpl - Moskow 2024
1 - 2 Strategic Mars - Core Dump (unreleased)
0 - 3 Zorax - 1942 (MSX2)
2 - 1 Undeadline - Ankanbe Dragon
2 - 1 Princess Maker - Wizard's Lair
3 - 0 Mirror Maze (Peach Up) - Cannon Ball
2 - 1 Seed of Dragon - Troxx